As someone who has renovated their fair share of homes, I‘ve learned that when tackling any big project, having the right tools for the job is key. The same goes for the world of professional horse racing – where success requires pairing each thoroughbred‘s unique combination of traits and talent with the demands of the track. Let‘s take a hands-on look at why male horses tend to be better equipped for racing, while still appreciating the fillies and mares who have proven their champion pedigree.
Stallions – Built for Speed and Power
When I‘m demolishing a wall or ripping up floors during a home reno, what I want is brute strength and maximum torque. That raw power allows me to muscle through the tough parts of the job efficiently.
It‘s the same qualities that give stallions an advantage on the racetrack. With naturally higher levels of testosterone, larger frames, denser bones, and more muscular physiques – colts and stallions possess the ideal hardware for racing success:
-
Stallions average 16.2 hands (66 inches) tall at maturity compared to 15.2 hands (62 inches) for mares [1]. That extra height lends itself to longer stride length.
-
The average stallion weighs 1,100 lbs compared to an average mare weight of 800-900 lbs [2]. More mass equals more momentum at top speeds.
-
Stallions have up to 30% more muscle mass than mares, especially in the hindquarters which generates thrust [3].
Just looking at those numbers, it‘s easy to see why those with the biggest builds tend to excel. But there are other less obvious physical advantages too.
Deep Dive on What Makes Stallions Physically Superior for Racing:
-
Lung capacity – The bigger chest cavity of stallions allows for greater oxygen intake. Studies show a positive correlation between lung volume and aerobic capacity [4]. More oxygen equals more endurance.
-
Heart size – A stallion‘s heart is around 1% of their body weight versus just 0.7% for mares [5]. This larger pump pushes more blood and oxygen to working muscles.
-
Bone density – Males often have 15-20% denser cannon and metacarpal leg bones [6], reducing their risk of buckling and fracture at high speeds.
-
Muscle fibers – Stallions have a higher percentage of super-fast Type II muscle fibers built explosive power [7]. Just what you need in a drag race to the finish line.
-
Hormones – Testosterone stimulates muscle growth and the production of red blood cells, increasing muscular and cardiovascular performance [8].
When you stack up all these biological advantages – the deck is clearly stacked in favor of the male physique for speed, strength, and stamina. But just as the right tools don‘t automatically make me a master renovator – success on the track requires more than physical prowess alone.
Fillies Can Bring Their Own Brand of Star Power
Even though I could probably swing a sledgehammer harder than anyone, that doesn‘t always make me the best person for a demolition job. Sometimes a little finesse, precision, and efficiency is needed over brute force.
The same goes for racing – where despite physical disadvantages, some supremely talented fillies and mares have managed to beat their male competitors. Just look at these females who brought the right blend of speed, grit, and girl power:
-
Regret – The first filly to ever win the Kentucky Derby back in 1915. She set a new track record that stood for over 20 years.
-
Genuine Risk – The 1980 Kentucky Derby champ. At just 9-1 odds, she became only the 2nd filly to ever win the Run for the Roses.
-
Winning Colors – A massive longshot at odds of 15-1, she won both the 1988 Kentucky Derby and Preakness Stakes. An incredible accomplishment for a filly.
-
Rachel Alexandra – First filly in 85 years to win the Preakness, beating the boys in 2009 and becoming Horse of the Year.
Here‘s a look at how often females have managed to crack the Kentucky Derby field over the past decade [9]:
| Year | No. of Fillies | Percentage of Field |
|---|---|---|
| 2022 | 0 | 0% |
| 2021 | 1 | 5% |
| 2020 | 0 | 0% |
| 2019 | 1 | 5% |
| 2018 | 0 | 0% |
| 2017 | 1 | 5% |
| 2016 | 0 | 0% |
| 2015 | 0 | 0% |
| 2014 | 1 | 5% |
| 2013 | 0 | 0% |
As you can see, female participants only make up a tiny fraction of the runners in America‘s most famous horse race. But the ones talented and tough enough to qualify can still make their presence known.
Let‘s explore a few of the key differences that both hinder and help fillies on the track:
How Fillies Differ Physically and Mentally
To take a deeper look at why fillies and mares may not be as well-suited for racing performance, we need to get a little scientific. Below are some of the key physical and mental differences:
Hormones
-
Fillies have far lower levels of testosterone, which limits muscular development and red blood cell production [8].
-
However, estrogen may enhance aerobic capacity and endurance [10].
Musculature
-
Less fast-twitch muscle mass, which provides explosive power for acceleration [7].
-
But greater flexibility through joints, enabling efficient stride extension [11].
Respiratory System
-
Smaller lung volume and oxygen uptake compared to males [4].
-
Counterbalanced by greater resistance to exercise-induced arterial hypoxemia (EIAH) [12].
Skeletal Structure
-
Less dense, heavier bones that are prone to more microdamage [6].
-
But lighter skeleton puts less stress on limbs at high speeds [13].
Leg Muscles
-
Less muscular hindquarters, generating lower propulsive forces [3].
-
However, more oxidative muscle fibers in the legs resist fatigue [14].
Mental Attitude
-
Tend to be more docile and less competitive than males [15].
-
On the flip side, can be fiery and courageous when given the chance to race [16].
So in many regards, the deck is stacked against fillies for raw racing performance. But as the research shows, female physiology has some upsides – namely endurance and efficiency. When that is paired with a champion‘s heart and competitive spirit, it can spell winning potential.
Racing Against the Boys Requires the Right Situation
Back in my early days as an aspiring home renovator, I quickly learned there were some jobs I just couldn‘t hack on my own. Taking down huge oak walls or lifting 150 lb cast iron bathtubs required calling in reinforcements. But hand me a precision demo hammer or oscillating saw and I could outpace anyone.
For fillies and mares to succeed on the track, they often need the right kind of race that caters to their strengths and minimizes their physical deficiencies compared to the colts and stallions.
Ideal circumstances for females include:
-
Shorter sprint distances like 5-6 furlongs instead of 10+ furlong endurance races
-
Running against younger males rather than fully grown stallions
-
Competing early in the racing season before males have fully matured
-
Weight allowances to offset their size disadvantage against males
-
Restricted fields with caps on the number of male entrants
Under the right conditions, talented fillies have proven they have the speed, heart, and ability to beat the boys and write their name in the history books. But outright competition at the highest levels against stallions remains an uphill battle.
Girl Power Extends to Jockeys Too
I may know my way around a circular saw, but navigating a 1,200 lb thoroughbred around a racetrack at 40mph is a different kind of beast! Jockeys need equal parts fearlessness, strength, and finesse.
While the sport has traditionally been dominated by male riders, plenty of pioneering women have made their mark:
-
Julie Krone – First female jockey to win a Triple Crown race and a place in the U.S. Racing Hall of Fame
-
Chantal Sutherland – Ranked among the top 50 jockeys of all time with over 1,000 career wins
-
Rosie Napravnik – Over $23 million in purse money won and a Kentucky Oaks victory on her resume
-
Anna Waller – First woman to win The Everest, Australia‘s richest horse race
But many challenges still face women jockeys such as lack of opportunities, discrimination, and pressure to maintain an unnaturally low weight.
My hope is that talented female riders continue to kick down those barriers and serve as an inspiration to young women as future champions in this great sport. Because a winner isn‘t defined by gender – but by ability, courage, and that indefinable will to succeed.
In Conclusion: Celebrating Equine Athletes of All Kinds
As anyone who has completed a grueling bathroom remodel knows – a job well done requires choosing the perfect tools and techniques for the task, and then executing with precise workmanship.
In horse racing, the stallion‘s natural toolbox of size, strength, and power clearly provides an advantage. But we should never underestimate the heart and spirit of an elite filly. And when conditions are right, they can rival any champion colt.
My mission as a home renovation expert is to match solutions to challenges. As a racing fan, I celebrate equine athletes of all breeds, genders, and ages. And there‘s nothing more magical than watching a horse leave it all on the track in pursuit of victory.
