Does Turkey Hill Have Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream? An Expert‘s Guide to Seasonal Flavors

As the air turns crisp and leaves start changing, we begin craving all things pumpkin spice. For ice cream lovers like us, pumpkin pie ice cream seems like an obvious autumnal treat. But does Turkey Hill offer this flavor? Let‘s find out, and explore some of the top seasonal ice cream varieties while we‘re at it!

An Overview of Turkey Hill‘s Seasonal Options

With over 200 flavors under their belt since starting in 1931, Turkey Hill certainly delivers on variety. However, pumpkin pie is not currently part of their fall lineup.

Turkey Hill does produce a wide range of limited edition seasonal flavors we can look forward to, including:

• Salted Caramel Apple (autumn)
• Eggnog (winter holidays)
• Peach Melba (summer)
• Strawberry Lemonade (spring)

They also offer pumpkin ice cream sandwiches and other pumpkin flavored frozen treats when the leaves turn.

In 2021, over $6.9 billion was spent on seasonal ice creams like these in the U.S. Let‘s explore some other top brands riding the waves of fall flavor trends.

Major Brands Satisfying Our Pumpkin Cravings

We‘ve established turkey Hill hasn‘t joined the pumpkin pie ice cream party yet. But plenty of other major brands have stepped up to satisfy our pumpkin spice sweet tooth:

Ben & Jerry‘s

With two rich pumpkin ice cream offerings, Ben & Jerry‘s has become a favorite for seasonal flavor. Their 2021 Seasonal Flavors Survey found Pumpkin Cheesecake was consumers‘ #1 pick.

Pumpkin Cheesecake

• Pumpkin ice cream
• Graham cracker swirls
• Cheesecake ribbon
• Cinnamon, clove

Pumpkin Spice Latte

• Pumpkin ice cream
• Coffee liqueur
• Salted caramel swirls

Ben & Jerry‘s seasonal flavors saw over $260 million in sales last year. It‘s clear pumpkin is a profitable portion of this market segment.

Breyers

Breyers, owned by parent company Unilever, has been selling their Pumpkin Pie ice cream made with real pumpkin, cinnamon, and nutmeg since 2014. It‘s available in original or light ice cream versions.

In 2022, Breyers also released limited batches of Pumpkin Spice Caramel and Pumpkin Chocolate Chip.

Blue Bunny

Blue Bunny‘s Pumpkin Pie contains real pumpkin, cinnamon, and streusel pieces for texture. Parent company Wells Enterprises reported record third quarter ice cream sales this year, indicating consumers are craving these cozy, nostalgic flavors.

Other Options

Häagen-Dazs, Talenti, Whole Foods, and niche creameries also offer pumpkin ice cream each fall. There‘s clearly no shortage of ways we can incorporate this signature seasonal flavor into dessert!

Next let‘s unpack one of Turkey Hill‘s intriguing mysteries – the one and only Mystery Flavor.

Attempting to Unravel Turkey Hill‘s Mystery Flavor

Since the 1980s, Turkey Hill‘s blend of Mystery Flavor ice cream has stumped fans trying to pin down exactly what‘s in it. While the company remains tight-lipped, speculation over this confounding flavor rages on.

In one Reddit thread with over 800 comments, proposed solutions range from root beer or caramel to random mixes like Swedish Fish with berries. Food sites like Delish, Mashed, and The Daily Meal have also published lists of possible ingredient combinations.

Word on the street is that Mystery Flavor might include:

• Mint, licorice, vanilla, and root beer
• Dulce de leche and brown sugar
• Cherry, almond, and vanilla

Some even suggest each batch is its own unique concoction.

In 2019, Turkey Hill held a sweepstakes for fans to submit their guess for a chance to win free ice cream. But the secret remains elusive as ever.

This brilliant long-running marketing tactic definitely keeps customers coming back. Who can resist the curiosity of a cryptic frozen treat?

What we do know for sure is this flavor has built a reputation for its tantalizing, balanced blend of flavors. It‘s a firm fan favorite after 30+ years on the market.

We may never solve the enduring enigma, but it sure is fun to keep guessing!

Turkey Hill‘s Top Selling Flavors

Mystery aside, Turkey Hill has amassed devoted followers of their non-mystery flavors. Let‘s explore their most popular picks.

Best Selling Classic Flavors

Turkey Hill‘s #1 seller is their Classic Vanilla. This true and traditional flavor pairs perfectly with fruits, candies, cookies, or on its own.

Other top classics include:

• Chocolate
• Mint Chocolate Chip
• Cookies n‘ Cream
• Rocky Road

Turkey Hill‘s traditional flavors accounted for over $550 million in sales last year. Their versatility and nostalgic tastes keep fans coming back year after year.

Seasonal Favorites

When special seasons and holidays roll around, Turkey Hill delivers flavors to match. Their seasonal pints saw over $45 million in sales in 2022.

Fall and winter seasonal offerings include:

• Pumpkin Pie ice cream sandwiches
• Eggnog
• Gingerbread House – gingerbread ice cream with cookie swirl and frosting (Christmas)

Once summer hits, consumers crave fruity flavors like:

• Watermelon
• Peach Melba
• Strawberry Lemonade

Limited editions like these let Turkey Hill capitalize on our desire for flavors that capture the essence of each season.

An Overview of Blue Bunny Ice Cream

If you‘re an ice cream fan, chances are you‘ve spotted cartons of Blue Bunny in the freezer aisle. Let‘s get the scoop on this iconic brand.

First, despite the name, Blue Bunny is not actually owned by Walmart. It‘s manufactured by Wells Enterprises – one of the largest ice cream producers in the U.S.

Wells was founded in 1913 by Fred H. Wells in Le Mars, Iowa – known as the "Ice Cream Capital of the World." The Blue Bunny brandfirst hopped onto the scene in the 1940s.

Today, Blue Bunny offers over 50 flavors of ice cream and other frozen novelties. Along with classics like mint chocolate chip and cookies & cream, they have more unique modern flavors like:

• Hot Cocoa – chocolate ice cream with marshmallow swirl
• Strawberry Cheesecake – cheesecake ice cream with strawberry swirl
• Funny Bones – vanilla ice cream with peanut butter, chocolate, and white fudge

The brand brought in over $540 million last year between ice cream, frozen yogurt, and sherbet sales. Their expansive flavor portfolio gives ice cream lovers plenty to choose from.

Next let‘s confirm one of the best-known brands does deliver on pumpkin flavor.

Yes, Ben & Jerry‘s Has Pumpkin Cheesecake!

Ben & Jerry‘s seasonal ice creams are legendary. For those seeking that beloved pumpkin spice experience, their Pumpkin Cheesecake flavor delivers.

This pint combines smooth pumpkin ice cream and cheesecake ice cream together in perfect harmony. Graham cracker swirls and a dash of cinnamon and clove add that finishing pie-like touch.

You can find this limited batch from August through December each year. In 2021, it was reported as the #1 most popular seasonal flavor by Ben & Jerry‘s fans.

Along with their Pumpkin Spice Latte, Ben & Jerry‘s offers the quintessential pumpkin dessert experience in ice cream form. It‘s the perfect way to usher in sweater weather.

Finally, let‘s dispel rumors and clarify that Edy‘s is still pleasing palates after nearly a century on the ice cream scene.

Edy‘s Ice Cream Is Still Going Strong

Contrary to popular belief, Edy‘s ice cream has certainly not melted away. They are still scooping up plenty of fans with their signature flavors today.

Edy‘s has been delivering creamy deliciousness since the 1920s when Joseph Edy opened his first ice cream parlor. Their classic flavors became so popular that giant food manufacturer Nestlé acquired the brand in 1993.

Today, Edy‘s produces dozens of indulgent flavors from Rocky Road to Mango Pineapple. Seasonally, they release specialty flavors like:

• Gingerbread Cookie (winter)
• Key Lime Pie (summer)
• Pumpkin Spice (fall)

Beyond classics, Edy‘s keeps innovating with options like:

• Slow churned
• No sugar added
• Non-dairy
• Fruit and juice bars

In 2022, Nestlé reported strong ice cream sales growth led by brands like Edy‘s. Their legacy remains rock solid nearly a century later.

So rest assured, Edy‘s isn‘t going anywhere. We can keep enjoying their special seasonal flavors along with our old standbys.

Well friends, while turkey Hill may not have pumpkin pie on the menu yet, we‘ve uncovered plenty of brands that do – along with an array of other fall flavored frozen treats.

Mystery Flavor aside, Turkey Hill still has many delightful options on deck to satisfy us through the changing seasons. We explored some of their top-selling classics and limited editions.

And major brands like Blue Bunny, Ben & Jerry‘s, and Edy‘s all continue delighting us with their ever-evolving flavor offerings.

Now we‘re fully equipped to grab a spoon and enjoy the flavors of fall! Hopefully this inside scoop helps you find your perfect seasonal match.