Is a Built-In Shower Bench Worth It? The Ultimate Guide

As an expert in home renovations and bath design, I‘m often asked if installing a built-in shower bench is worth the investment. After helping install hundreds of custom shower benches over my career, I can confidently say they offer clear benefits that boost comfort, convenience, accessibility, and safety during showering for all users. However, built-in benches also come with some extra costs and maintenance that require consideration.

This detailed guide examines all the pros, cons, installation tips, and design options to help you make the right decision for your home. I‘ll share insights from my years of experience to provide you with an in-depth look at everything involved with incorporating a built-in bench into your shower design.

What Exactly is a Built-In Shower Bench?

Before weighing the pros and cons, let‘s start by reviewing what defines a built-in shower bench. A built-in shower bench is a permanent seating fixture that is integrated directly into the structure of the shower enclosure.

Unlike portable shower chairs or stools that can be moved in and out, a true built-in bench is permanently secured and cannot be easily removed. The bench consists of:

• Seat – Typically made of tile, stone, solid surface, or waterproof wood. The seat tops are most often rectangular, L-shaped, or corner shaped.

• Support Structure – This provides underlying support and is attached securely to the shower framing and walls.

• Waterproofing – All seams and joints are sealed using waterproof grout, caulk, and adhesives during installation.

• Drainage – Most are designed with a slight slope or holes to allow water drainage.

The size, placement, materials, and accessories like grab bars or shelving can be customized to your space and needs. Let‘s look closer at the key pros and cons.

The Pros of Installing a Built-In Shower Bench

1. Provides a Convenient Place to Sit While Showering

The number one advantage is having a comfy spot to sit while you shower! For shaving legs, washing feet, or just taking a relaxing steam, a built-in seat makes these tasks easier and more pleasant. In a Consumer Reports survey, over 70% of respondents said an in-shower seat was an important feature to them.

2. Improved Accessibility and Mobility

For those with disabilities, limited mobility, or age-related conditions, entering and exiting a shower can be difficult and dangerous. Shower benches allow safe and stable transfers in and out of the enclosure and provide secure, comfortable seating. This makes showering accessible for millions of elderly and disabled individuals. According to a 2020 report by the CDC, approx. 61 million adults in the U.S. have a disability that impacts major life activities. The prevalence is highest among adults aged 65 years or older.

3. Enhanced Safety and Stability

Standing in a wet, slippery shower for an extended time can be risky, especially for older adults or those with physical limitations. Per CDC data, about 234,000 older adults are hospitalized each year for fall injuries that occur in the bathroom. Having a sturdy, permanently installed seat offers safe, secure seating and reduces the chance of slips or falls. Grab bars can also easily be incorporated for additional stability when standing or sitting.

4. Storage Solutions

One thing I love about built-in benches is they often allow dual functionality. The space beneath the seat can be designed for organized storage of shower essentials. Recessed shelving, sliding baskets, and cabinets built into the bench provide easy access to toiletries while showering. No more clutter of bottles on the floor or shower caddies hanging from the shower head!

5. Stylish Focal Point

Along with being functional, a custom built-in bench incorporated into your shower design adds aesthetic appeal. Available in natural stone, tile, glass, and wood, they make a stylish statement. Incorporating complementary patterns, textures, and colors allows you to create a true showpiece that enhances the entire bathroom.

6. Boosts Resale Value

Upgrading to a built-in bench and curbless, accessible shower shows investement into the home. This modernization appeals to all generations of buyers – from aging boomers to millennials to young families. This makes showers with built-in benches highly desirable and can boost a home‘s resale value.

According to Remodeling Magazine‘s 2021 Cost vs. Value Report, contemporary spa bathrooms with curbless showers rank #3 for return on investment, recouping about 70% of costs.

The Potential Cons to Weigh

While the pros clearly outweigh the cons in my opinion, there are some downsides of built-in benches to consider:

1. Higher Upfront Installation Costs

Especially compared to portable options, the installed cost of built-in benches is higher since they require more labor, materials, and customization. The national average installed cost ranges from $500 – $2000. Custom stone or tile builds with added cabinetry or shelving can cost up to $5000 when professionally installed.

2. Ongoing Maintenance Is Required

The grout lines, seams, and caulked joints used in installation must be kept well-sealed and maintained over time to prevent water damage, mold growth, and deterioration. This means reapplying sealants and caulk 2-3 times per year. The bench surface also needs periodic deep cleaning.

3. Potential Reduction of Shower Space

For compact shower enclosures, the footprint of a built-in bench takes up valuable space inside. For some, the fixed bench placement can feel restrictive versus having an open shower area. Careful measurement and placement is key for a custom fit. Corner-installed benches help maximize open floorspace.

4. Risk of Leaks if Not Properly Sealed

To avoid water related issues, expert installation and proper ongoing caulk/seal maintenance are a must. Cracks, deteriorated caulk, or damaged seams near the bench can allow water penetration and cause hidden leaks and mold over time if not addressed quickly.

5. Difficult Access for Cleaning

Depending on the design and surrounding walls, getting to the underside of the bench can be tricky for thorough cleaning. Standing water, soap scum, and mildew can accumulate in this area if not cared for. I recommend incorporating removable panels or other access points into the bench during installation for easier maintenance.

Now that we‘ve covered the central pros and cons, let‘s look at common built-in shower bench materials and positioning placement.

Built-In Shower Bench Materials

Custom built-in shower benches allow you to select from many different surface materials. Consider factors like your overall budget, the shower aesthetics, and the level of maintenance you wish to take on:

• Tile: Provides a seamless custom look and abundant style options. Grout requires ongoing sealing. Installation is best left to tile professionals.

• Natural Stone: For an elegant spa-like look. More expensive but extremely durable when properly sealed. Avoid very porous sedimentary stones.

• Solid Surface: Affordable, integrated construction prevents seams that can leak. Prone to scratches and stains without proper cleaning regimen.

• Teak Wood: Offers a rich, warm look but requires careful waterproofing and maintenance. Annual re-sealing needed.

• Tempered Glass: Sleek and modern but higher cost. Seating surface can be uncomfortably cold. Significantly heavier to install securely.

• Acrylic: Economical option that is easy to clean. Mold-resistant. Seams are visible and may need resealing over time.

Placement Tips for Built-In Shower Benches

Proper planning of the size, shape, and placement prior to installation is key to creating a comfortable and functional built-in bench:

• Height: Install the bench seat at 16-18 inches high. This provides an ADA-compliant height for safe transfers and comfort.

• Position: Locate towards the back wall, allowing a clear walkway into the shower. Avoid directly under showerhead.

• Depth: Standard depth is between 15-20 inches deep. Deeper is more comfortable for taller users.

• Angle: Position at a slight outward angle of 5-15 degrees for safe ingress/egress.

• Grab Bars: Install supportive grab bars alongside the bench for stability and assistance standing up.

• Measure Carefully! Take detailed measurements and create a drawing of the envisioned layout prior to installation. This helps ensure a custom fit.

Estimated Costs – What‘s the Investment?

As a home renovation specialist, I‘m often asked – what‘s the cost to install a built-in shower bench? The price can vary widely based on:

• Type of material chosen – natural stone and tile are most expensive, followed by glass and solid surface materials. Acrylic is the most budget-friendly.

• Overall size of the shower bench. Larger = higher cost.

• Added features like integrated shelving, cabinets, patterns, inlays, etc.

• Accessories like grab bars, curbs, and drains.

• Complexity of the installation and plumbing adjustments needed.

• Professional installation vs DIY.

Here are some typical price ranges I see for basic built-in bench installations:

• Tile or Stone Benches – $1200 – $4000+

• Solid Surface or Acrylic – $700 – $2000

• Glass or Wood – $800 – $3000+

I recommend getting multiple bids from contractors to find the best deal. Be sure to verify they are insured, licensed, have shower installation experience, and will pull proper permits if needed.

Maintaining Your Shower Bench to Prevent Mold and Mildew

To keep your built-in bench looking pristine and prevent slippery mildew from forming, be sure to:

• Wipe down the bench with a soft cloth after every use to prevent soap scum buildup. I keep a designated bench towel handy.

• Deep clean monthly using a non-abrasive bathroom cleaner safe for your bench material. Carefully scrub corners and crevices.

• Squeegee excess water off the bench after showering. This helps surfaces fully dry.

• Keep the bathroom‘s exhaust fan running for at least 30 minutes after showering to reduce humidity.

• Check caulk lines around the bench every 1-2 months. Reapply waterproof silicone caulk anywhere cracking appears.

• Apply new grout sealant if you notice seams looking worn or discolored.

Following this routine maintenance regimen eliminates 99% of mold and mildew issues in my remodeling experience.

Customization – Make it Uniquely You

The ability to fully customize built-in benches is one of my favorite features. Here are some amazing design options I‘ve incorporated for clients:

Shape – Choose from rectangular, L-shaped, triangular, curved, or corner designs. Get creative!

Tiling – Mix textures, patterns, inlays, borders, and colors. Contrast grout lines make tile patterns pop.

Size – Determine the ideal length and depth for your space. Benches range from 2 to 5 feet long.

Shelving – Great for keeping toiletries organized and handy. Open or enclosed cabinets offer concealed storage.

Grab Bars – Strategically place for assistance standing and transferring on and off the seat.

Patterns – Use glass, stone, or tile inlays to create geometric, nature-inspired, or abstract designs.

Edges – Soften edges with bullnose tiles, curbs, or trim. Add definition with decorative listellos or molding strips.

Lighting – Install battery-powered or hardwired lighting to illuminate the bench area for safety. Waterproof LED strips work beautifully.

Drainage – Ensure proper drainage by tilting the bench slightly toward the drain. Add holes if needed.

The design options for built-in benches are truly endless. They provide you with a fun way to put your personal spin and style on your dream shower.

Special Considerations for Accessibility and Safety

To make shower benches as comfortable and safe as possible for elderly and disabled users, I recommend:

• Non-Slip Surfaces – Use textured tile or appliques on the seat to prevent slipping when wet. Contrasting colors also help define the seat edge.

• Grab Bars – Install sturdy grab bars in helpful locations to assist with transfers and stability.

• Adjustable Showerhead – Allows all users to adjust the height and angle as needed. Choose a handheld style.

• Curbless Entry – Eliminate any threshold or step up into the shower for easy wheelchair and walker access.

• Removable Seat Section – Section off part of the bench to accommodate a shower wheelchair if needed.

• ADA Compliance – Follow all ADA regulations for proper seat height, grab bars, and allowances.

If safety and accessibility are top concerns, be sure to have an occupational therapist or assistive technology specialist review your plans to optimize the design.

Hiring a Contractor vs. DIY Installation

Installing a fully waterproof, customized built-in bench requires advanced technical skills. Here are key factors to weigh if debating DIY vs. professional installation:

Waterproofing Expertise – This is crucial to prevent leaks. Professionals have specialized tools, materials, and skills to properly seal the entire bench.

Structural Reinforcement – The bench must be very securely attached to shower framing to support weight and force. Most DIYers do not have the knowledge or ability to do this properly.

Tiling/Stonework – Cutting and fitting materials like tile and natural stone is an art that takes years of experience to master.

Plumbing Adjustments – Existing shower lines may need to be rerouted to accommodate the new bench footprint.

Material Handling – Many bench materials like stone, tile, and glass are extremely heavy and fragile. Professionals have specialized equipment to maneuver them safely during installation.

Permits – Depending on your area, plumbing and electrical permits may be required, especially if adjusting existing lines. Professionals can ensure proper codes and permitting.

While Do-It-Yourself projects can be rewarding, I encourage you to weigh the complexity factors before taking on a built-in bench installation yourself. Your safest bet is hiring a professional with expertise in bath remodeling and bench construction.

Answering Common Questions About Built-In Benches

Here are answers to some of the most frequently asked questions I receive about installing built-in shower benches:

Are built-in benches really worth the higher cost?

For users needing ergonomic seating, stability, accessibility, and convenience in the shower, absolutely. The benefits outweigh the price long-term. Plus, you’ll boost resale value.

Where is the best placement in the shower enclosure?

I recommend installing benches towards the rear of the enclosure, allowing clear entry access. Avoid positioning directly under the showerhead spray.

Can I add one to my existing shower?

In most cases, yes. Some tile removal and plumbing modifications will be required. Hire a professional for proper structural reinforcement and waterproofing.

How difficult are they to clean and maintain?

With proper sealing applied during installation and regular maintenance to re-caulk and re-grout as needed, cleaning is quite manageable. Stay on top of wiping benches after use and monthly deep cleaning.

How much space do built-in benches take up?

The footprint is fairly minimal. Benches are typically 15-20 inches deep. Corner benches help maximize open floor space. Proper measuring ensures a custom fit.

What is the standard or recommended seating height?

For optimal ergonomics and transfers, building codes specify 16-18 inches as the recommended seating height. Grab bars add helpful stability and support.

The Bottom Line

While requiring careful planning and a higher initial investment, in my professional opinion, upgrading to a built-in shower bench can be a rewarding home improvement. The array of benefits – from added comfort and convenience to improved accessibility and safety – make built-in benches a worthwhile addition for many homeowners. Their stylish, spa-like aesthetic also enhances the beauty of any bathroom‘s design.

With proper installation from an experienced professional and routine maintenance to combat mold and mildew, built-in benches offer an excellent ROI that can be enjoyed for decades. I hope this comprehensive guide provides the details you need to decide if integrating a custom bench into your shower is right for you. Please feel free to reach out with any additional questions!