Hey there! Lillie here, your friendly neighborhood renovator and pizza dough expert. If you‘re looking to make tasty homemade pizza dough, you‘ve got a big decision to make – should you mix and knead it by hand or use a stand mixer? I‘m here to walk you through the pros and cons so you can decide what works best for your needs.
Kneading By Hand is More Authentic
Let‘s start with hand kneading. This traditional technique is used by pizza chefs for a reason – it simply makes better dough! Here‘s why:
-
You can really feel the dough and adjust as needed. Adding a bit more flour or water until you get that perfect silky, elastic dough ball.
-
Kneading by hand incorporates air bubbles that expand during rising. This gives the crust a lovely airy texture.
-
It allows you to work the dough to just right consistency. Not too dry and not too sticky.
-
The friction warms the dough, helping develop more complex flavors.
In fact, one study from the American Chemical Society found hand-kneaded dough had lower levels of oxidative stress compounds compared to dough mixed in a machine. This results in better flavor and aroma.
Hand kneading does take more time and elbow grease – usually 8-10 minutes of pushing, folding and pressing the dough. But in my opinion, the extra effort pays off in superior crust and flavor.
Mixers Are More Convenient
Now let‘s talk about stand mixers. These popular appliances make quick work of pizza dough with their powerful motors and handy dough hooks.
The key advantages of a mixer include:
-
Speed: A stand mixer can knead dough in 5-10 minutes rather than 10-15 minutes by hand. Great time savings.
-
Consistency: The mixer takes the guesswork out of kneading. Settings don‘t vary batch to batch like hand kneading.
-
Multitasking: You can work on sauce, toppings, etc while the mixer kneads.
-
Effortless: Simply add your ingredients and let the machine do the work. No physical labor required.
According to KitchenAid, their stand mixers can knead up to 2.5 times faster than hand kneading. For instance, their 5-quart mixer can knead enough dough for 5 pizzas in just 4 minutes. Pretty impressive results!
The only potential drawbacks are over-mixing can damage gluten development and kill yeast cells. But as long as you follow recipe directions, a stand mixer will produce delicious dough easily.
Hand Mixing vs. Stand Mixer – Making the Choice
So when it comes down to it, which method is better for pizza dough – hand mixing or stand mixer?
-
For authentic artisan-style pizza with perfect chewy crust, hand kneading is the way to go.
-
For quick weeknight doughs, choose the convenience of a mixer.
-
Making dough in large batches is easier with a stand mixer.
-
New bakers may want to start with a mixer until they master technique.
My advice is to give both methods a try and see what works for your lifestyle and preferences. And be sure to use recipes specifically developed for each mixing method.
Want to learn more hands-on tips and tricks for pizza dough? I‘ve got you covered with my online masterclass – just visit www.lilliethehandymama.com to sign up.
Now get kneading and start crafting your own homemade pizzas – I can‘t wait to see your delicious creations!
Your pizza pal,
Lillie
Common Pizza Dough Mixing Questions
Here are answers to some of the most frequently asked questions about mixing and kneading pizza dough:
What‘s the best technique for hand kneading dough?
- To hand knead properly, start by pushing the dough outward while stretching the outer edges of the dough in towards the center. The dough should be folded underneath as you work it.
- Be sure to periodically turn the dough a quarter turn while kneading. This ensures even stretching and gluten development.
- Each stretch and push should be done firmly but avoid overworking the dough. It should feel elastic and smooth, not stiff.
- It takes around 8-10 minutes of consistent kneading until the dough passes the "windowpane test" – where it can be stretched very thin without tearing.
How long should I knead dough with a stand mixer?
- Most pizza dough recipes call for kneading in a stand mixer for 5-10 minutes.
- Set a timer and keep an eye on the dough ball as it kneads. Stop mixing if it starts climbing up the dough hook or looks overworked.
- The dough is ready when it‘s smooth, passes the windowpane test, and springs back when poked.
What speed should I use to knead dough in a mixer?
- Start mixing your dough on low speed (setting 2 on a KitchenAid) to combine ingredients.
- Once combined, increase to medium speed (4-6 on a KitchenAid) for the kneading stage. Higher speeds can overwork the dough.
- Use the dough hook, not beaters, to properly knead dough in a mixer.
How many batches of dough can a stand mixer handle?
-
Most home stand mixers with a 5-7 quart capacity can handle:
- 1-2 pounds of bread dough
- 2-3 pizza dough balls (each 1 lb)
-
Doubling a dough recipe is usually fine, but avoid going above 3 lbs total dough or it may strain the motor.
-
For high volume dough production, choose a commercial grade mixer with at least a 10 quart capacity.
I hope these tips help you master the art of pizza dough mixing. Let me know if you have any other questions – happy baking!
