Is Raiden Shogun better than Nahida?

tags

After carefully analyzing their abilities, team roles, and in-game performance, I believe Raiden Shogun is slightly better overall compared to Nahida. However, Nahida is an exceptionally strong Dendro support that enables new playstyles. Let‘s take a deep dive into how these two characters compare.

Raiden Shogun Overview

Known as the Electro Archon and ruler of Inazuma, the Raiden Shogun arrived in Version 2.1 as one of the most anticipated characters in Genshin Impact‘s history. As a 5-star polearm user, she ascended to prominence not only due to her Archon status, but also her uniquely powerful kit.

Some key strengths of Raiden‘s kit:

• Her Elemental Skill, Eye of Stormy Eye, deals excellent off-field Electro damage at C0. At higher constellations, this skill becomes one of the best sources of continuous Electro application in the game.

• Her Elemental Burst, Secret Art: Musou Shinsetsu, buffs Raiden‘s Electro damage and Energy recharge substantially. When used, it allows her to enter an extended powered-up state where she acts as an on-field DPS.

• During her Burst mode, Raiden strikes opponents with Raiden Shogun‘s attacks infused with Electro. These coordinated attacks have extremely high damage scaling.

• When any party member uses their Burst during Raiden‘s Burst mode, they gain a flat Energy restore based on Raiden‘s Energy Recharge. This allows her to function as a "universal battery" for teammates.

• As the Electro Archon, she has unique interactions with the Electro element through Ascension Talents. For example, she can convert Energy Recharge above 100% into bonus Electro DMG.

With this versatile kit, Raiden Shogun has carved out a niche as one of Genshin Impact‘s most popular and powerful characters since her release. She boasts usage rates of over 90% in Spiral Abyss teams and has generated massive revenue from her banners. I will cover Raiden‘s strengths, weaknesses, and best teams in more detail throughout this guide.

Nahida Overview

As the Dendro Archon, Nahida arrived in Version 3.2 bringing brand new possibilities for Dendro-focused teams. She immediately became a top-tier support option due to her unmatched Dendro application capabilities. Let‘s examine some key aspects of Nahida‘s kit:

• Her Elemental Skill, All Schemes to Know, allows Nahida to mark enemies with the Seed of Skandha. When enemies affected by the seeds take damage, they generate Dendro Cores that explode for AoE Dendro damage.

• Nahida‘s Elemental Burst, Illusory Heartbeat, creates a field that applies Dendro to any enemies within at set intervals. This field moves alongside your active character.

• Nahida‘s A1 passive talent grants her EM based on her Dendro DMG Bonus. With the right build, she can attain over 1000 EM easily to share with allies.

• Her A4 passive grants Nahida 200 EM after using her Burst, which further buffs Dendro reactions.

• At C2, tri-Karma Purification increases the damage of Bloom, Hyperbloom, and Burgeon reactions by 200% of Nahida‘s EM when she triggers them. This creates massive reaction damage potential.

With her Dendro application talents, Nahida unlocks team compositions centered around Bloom, Hyperbloom, Burgeon, and Spread reactions. However, as a new character she still needs to stand the test of time compared to Raiden.

Direct Comparison

Now that we‘ve covered their kits, let‘s directly compare Raiden Shogun and Nahida across some key attributes:

Flexibility

Winner: Raiden Shogun

Raiden fits seamlessly into many team archetypes. She enables compositions like Raiden Hypercarry, Raiden National, and Raiden Aggravate. Her battery ability works universally across all elements.

Nahida is more limited as either a Spread/Aggravate bot or Dendro reactor. She lacks the omni-compatibility of Raiden in drafts.

Damage Output

Winner: Raiden Shogun

During her Elemental Burst, Raiden‘s coordinated attacks can easily exceed 150k damage per second with proper investment. She also unlocks her C2 and C3 power spikes to amplify this further.

Nahida‘s damage is capped by reactions and her C2. She cannot compete with Raiden in raw damage numbers.

Energy Generation

Winner: Raiden Shogun

With ~200% ER, Raiden can restore 25-30 energy to all allies bursting during her Musou Isshin state. This gives her unmatched energy battery power.

Nahida provides no inherent energy generation. She still needs a battery herself to fund her 80 energy Burst.

Ease of Building

Winner: Nahida

Nahida only needs EM main stats from artifacts to maximize her buffing and reactions. This makes her very easy to build.

Raiden desires ATK%/Electro/CRIT artifacts along with 200%+ ER. Balancing these offensive stats is trickier.

Constellations

Winner: Tie

Both characters have their C2 power spike. Raiden‘s boosts her personal damage, while Nahida‘s amplifies reactions. Their remaining constellations are similarly impactful.

Overall, Raiden edges out Nahida in damage, flexibility, and energy restoration. However, Nahida wins in ease of building and bringing new Dendro teams online. Let‘s look deeper at their team roles.

Team Roles and Compositions

Raiden Shogun Team Roles

• Hypercarry: Raiden on field for 8+ seconds to maximize Musou Isshin damage

• Sub DPS: Quickswap Burst rotation focused on Maximizing ally damage/energy

Example teams:

• Raiden Hypercarry (Raiden, Sara, Kazuha, Bennett)
• Raiden National (Raiden, Xiangling, Xingqiu, Bennett)
• Raiden Aggravate (Raiden, Fischl, Dendro Traveler, Jean/Zhongli)

As you can see, Raiden‘s battery ability enables her to slot into many top-tier comps as either the hypercarry or sub DPS. Her teams have consistently topped Spiral Abyss usage charts every rotation.

Nahida Team Roles

• Enabler: Triggering Spread and Aggravate reactions
• Driver: Triggering Bloom, Hyperbloom, and Burgeon reactions

Example teams:

• Nahida Spread (Nahida, Fischl, Beidou, Zhongli)
• Nahida Hyperbloom (Nahida, Xingqiu, Beidou, Raiden)
• Burgeon Team (Nahida, Xiangling, Bennett, Xingqiu)

Nahida is specialized in enabling Dendro reaction focused teams by driving or triggering reactions. She currently has less team variety than Raiden, but provides new playstyle options.

Usage and Strength Over Time

It‘s also worth examining Raiden and Nahida‘s strength over the course of the lifespan of Genshin Impact.

Raiden Shogun has only gotten stronger over time as new artifacts, supports, and reactions have been introduced. The Dendro element expanded her team options even further.

As a new character, Nahida‘s long term power is still unproven. However, she shows potential to remain a top Dendro applicator for the foreseeable future.

Looking at Spiral Abyss usage rates shows how dominant Raiden has been over time:

Version	Raiden Usage	Nahida Usage
2.5	93%	N/A
2.8	95%	N/A
3.0	95%	N/A
3.2	96%	79%
3.3	97%	92%

These usage rates demonstrate Raiden‘s exceptional power and versatility over many Abyss rotations. It remains to be seen if Nahida can match this consistency long-term.

Constellations

Both characters gain significant power from their constellations. Here‘s a quick overview:

Raiden Shogun Constellations

• C1: Additional Skill charge
• C2: Buffs Burst DMG by 30%
• C3: Upgrades Musou Isshin Level
• C4: 60% Electro CRIT DMG during Musou Isshin
• C5: Reduces Musou Isshin CD by 3 seconds
• C6: Musou Isshin resets CD if party members Burst

Nahida Constellations

• C1: Extends Burst duration
• C2: 200% Dendro reaction DMG bonus
• C3: Talent Level +3
• C4: Removes ICD on Skill
• C5: Adds additional Burst charge
• C6: Doubles reaction AOE

For both characters, C2 and C6 provide the biggest power spikes. Raiden‘s C2 directly amplifies her personal damage, while Nahida‘s C2 boosts Dendro team damage.

Final Verdict

In summary, Raiden Shogun edges out Nahida overall based on:

• Higher personal damage potential
• More team flexibility and composition options
• Vastly superior energy generation
• Proven strength over many Abyss cycles

However, Nahida enables entirely new Dendro based reactions and her C2 makes her highly competitive for those playstyles. Her building is also more straightforward.

So in conclusion, while I believe Raiden is slightly "better" overall based on current evidence, Nahida brings tremendous value in enabling Bloom/Hyperbloom/Spread teams. Both are phenomenal options that excel at different roles. Choose based on your preferred playstyle and team needs.

Let me know if you have any other questions! I‘m happy to provide any additional analysis on these two amazing Archons.