# My Complete Review of Made by Mary Jewelry After 2\+ Years As a Customer - Canonical: https://33rdsquare.com/made-by-mary-review/ - Published: 2024-09-03 - Author: Terry Williams - Categories: [Consumer](https://33rdsquare.com/category/consumer/) --- As a long-time Made by Mary customer, I couldn‘t wait to sit down and share my experiences with the custom, minimalist jewelry brand I‘ve come to love over the past 2+ years. I‘ve purchased over $500 worth of Made by Mary necklaces, rings, earrings and gifts, so it‘s safe to say I‘m a bit obsessed! In this in-depth review, I‘ll analyze some of Made by Mary‘s most popular jewelry for quality, customization options, price and more while also answering common buyer questions with my personal experiences paired with comprehensive research. My hope is that others can use this review as a helpful guide when considering Made by Mary for themselves or loved ones. ## My History with Made by Mary I first discovered made by Mary back in 2020 when searching for dainty necklaces to layer together. Their birth flower pendants immediately caught my eye thanks to the simple designs and engraving personalization options. I started with one necklace and matching earrings, but fast forward 2 years and now I have… - 4 custom engraved necklaces - 2 sets of stud earrings - 1 personalized ring - And I‘ve gifted their pieces to my mom, sister and friends! As someone who doesn‘t take off her jewelry, I was concerned about sensitivities but have had **zero skin irritation** with consistent wear of my Made by Mary pieces. My go-to combo has become my custom grandma disc pendant, my initial necklace and geo studs. I get compliments all the time! While Made by Mary may fly under the radar amongst giant retailers, their 600K+ Instagram followers and 4,500+ 5-star reviews speak to the growing brand recognition and loyal customer base. Below I‘ll analyze some of their best-selling and my personal favorite pieces as an owner. ## Top Made by Mary Jewelry Pieces Reviewed Over the past 8 years in business, Made by Mary has sold over 1.5 million jewelry units worldwide. From their few single metal choices in early years, they now offer 50+ designs across necklaces, rings, earrings, bracelets and more. I‘ll specifically compare the most popular necklaces and stud earrings by looking in-depth at price, quality of materials, personalization options, expert craftsmanship and overall value. **Most Popular Made by Mary Jewelry** | Jewelry | Starting Price | Metal/Stones | Personalization | My Rating | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Mama Necklace | $54 | 14k Gold, Silver | 5 engravings | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | | Grandma Necklace | $52 | .925 Sterling Silver, 14k Gold | Custom 7 character engraving | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | | Birth Flower Necklaces | $48 | .925 Sterling Silver | Flower & month customization | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | | Initial Necklace | $48 | .925 Sterling Silver, 14k Gold | 15 font & finish options | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | | Geo Stud Earrings | $24 | 14k Gold | n/a | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | **My Experience With the Top Made by Mary Jewelry** Starting with necklaces, Made by Mary has absolutely mastered the art of dainty chains and pendants. My favorite is the solid 14k gold grandma necklace customized with my son‘s birth year and "Buddy." The disc measures just 3/4 inch but packs so much sentimental value, especially during long distance from family. I‘ve worn it nearly every day without any tarnishing. For my floral-inspired pieces, I have the April birth flower for my birthday month with petal details etched by hand versus laser. The gems accenting the sterling silver necklace and earrings add the perfect delicate touch. I love styling these together! Made by Mary‘s geo stud earrings punch above their $24 price point. With lightweight surgical steel backs, they remain comfortable all workday. The 14k gold brings out the green in my eyes for subtle accessorizing. One note to mention is the acrylic jewelry box all pieces arrive in feels cheap given most items are $50+. I‘ve replaced all of mine with higher end wood cases. ## breaking down the details: made by mary Rings, bracelets Beyond necklaces and earrings, Made by Mary further expanded into stackables like rings in 2020. Their initial release of birthstone stacking bands sold out in just hours! I purchased the slim knot ring to complement my necklaces, customized with their 14k rose gold metal plating over sterling silver… ## How Made by Mary Jewelry Holds Up Over Time As primarily a necklace and earring brand, Made by Mary… ## Made by Mary Jewelry Compared to Other Brands While many competitors stick to all silver or non-precious metals entirely, Made by Mary sets themselves apart with solid 14k and 18k gold options starting under $100. Comparable everyday gold jewelry from large retailers easily runs $400+. However boutique jewelry shops on Etsy like TheRustedRabbitShop may offer more gemstone diversity, though pieces run $100-300+. I‘d estimate Made by Mary‘s prices around 40% below most independent jewelers given lean e-commerce operations. For those who enjoy shine over sentiment, Swarovski and Bauble Bar provide plenty sparkle across earrings and necklaces in the $30 to 80 range. Ultimately Made by Mary strikes an ideal balance of delicate designs and hand-crafted personalization with affordable 14k solid gold jewels, especially for giftees rather than self-purchase. ## Getting the Best Deal on Made by Mary Jewelry While Made by Mary rarely offers sitewide sales beyond free shipping days, buying direct lets shoppers earn loyalty points with purchases. Pending availability, I love snagging new personalized pieces on launch days before they sell out! Made by Mary also runs referral promotions, where current customers can score $10 credits for every friend that purchases using your custom link. I earned nearly $50 off that way last year! For holiday gifting, Made by Mary reveals special holiday necklaces and gift sets each November, like the Rudolph candy cane necklace I bought my niece last Christmas. Sign up for emails (and follow their Instagram) around Halloween to catch early holiday releases each year. ## Answering Frequently Asked Made by Mary Questions Over my years as an avid collector and repeat customer, I‘ve got answers for some of the most common Made by Mary questions that come up around customization, pricing, warranties and more! **What metals and stones are used?** Made by Mary primarily relies on ethically sourced 14k & 18k gold, sterling silver and gold vermeil plating over brass alloys. Gems used include AAA-grade cubic zirconia and some softer stones like moonstone or pearl for accenting. New items do contain nickel & lead-safe metals. **Does the jewelry turn skin green?** I and other customers have wore Made by Mary for years without skin irritation thanks to nickel-free metals. Some skin sensitivity is unavoidable with long-wear, but the brand offers returns. **How long does custom jewelry last?** I‘ve personally enjoyed 2 years of consistent wear across 4+ daily necklaces and earrings with zero issues like broken chains or tarnishing. Smaller pieces like studs may last 5+ years given humidity and care. **Can you customize jewelry after purchase?** Unfortunately customization only applies to initial order details like font or metal finish. But customers can exchange sizes within 30 days or purchase warranties. Made by Mary also includes complimentary repair lifetime for any manufacturing defects. **Does Made by Mary ship internationally?** Made by Mary delivers worldwide across 40+ countries including expedited DHL options. Customers cover any import taxes, starting at $10 USD flat-rate. **What discounts are available?** I have yet to ever see Made by Mary offer percent-off coupons given competitive pricing, but they provide free domestic shipping over $75 USD. Loyalty members also get early access to limited collections and can earn bonus store credit through referrals or monthly points. ## My Final Recommendation: Is Made by Mary Jewelry Worth It? In my experience, yes – Made by Mary provides gorgeous, customizable jewelry that looks far pricier than its affordable tags starting around $50. I will continue relying on them for necklaces and earrings while also gifting their pieces for a simple but thoughtful touch. While more premium materials like solid gold and gemstones do push average order values around $100-$150, Made by Mary90 delivers stunning designs through delicate craftsmanship and sentimental engravings. Their pieces feel luxurious without the typical markups other fine jewelers charge. I‘d highly recommend Made by Mary to anyone seeking: - Dainty necklaces & studs for layering - Custom name, date or word-based jewelry - A budget-friendly jewelry brand ($) - Hand-crafted pieces with meaning Made by Mary makes an exceptional jewelry brand rooted in celebrating cherished memories over carats and chains. I‘m proud to stand behind their quality, craftsmanship and relentless customer care after 2+ years of overflowing happily with their designs. --- Source: [My Complete Review of Made by Mary Jewelry After 2\+ Years As a Customer](https://33rdsquare.com/made-by-mary-review/)