Should I Sell or Keep Legendary Pelts?

My recommendation is to sell legendary pelts once you‘ve crafted everything you need from them. While keeping the pelts allows you to craft unique clothing at any time, you can always re-acquire them from the trapper after selling. Selling frees up inventory space and provides an immediate injection of cash.

Legendary pelts in Red Dead Redemption 2 are highly coveted items that can be used to craft unique clothing and accessories. However, players are often faced with the dilemma of whether to sell legendary pelts for cash or keep them for crafting. This comprehensive guide will provide tips on the pros and cons of selling vs keeping these valuable pelts.

Overview of Legendary Pelts

Legendary animals are rare, challenging prey that can be tracked and hunted across the world of Red Dead Redemption 2. Defeating them rewards Arthur Morgan with valuable pelts, parts, and ingredients that can be used to craft unique clothing and tonics.

There are 16 legendary animals that can be hunted, from deadly predators like the Tatanka Bison to slinking swamp creatures like the Iguga Cougar. Below is a list of all legendary pelts and their baseline value when sold to the trapper:

As you can see, certain legendary pelts like the Tatanka Bison and Legendary Bear fetch much higher prices due to their rarity.

Pros of Selling Legendary Pelts

There are several advantages to selling legendary pelts rather than keeping them:

Immediate cash injection – Legendary pelts sell for good money at the trapper. This can give Arthur a nice boost of funds, especially early in the game. The Tatanka Bison pelt alone sells for a whopping $85.

Free up inventory space – Legendary pelts take up a ton of room on your horse and in camp. Selling them gives you capacity to store other hunting spoils and collectibles.

Unlock crafting options – An important thing to note is that selling a legendary pelt still allows you to craft items with it. The trapper keeps pelts you sell in his inventory permanently.

Source of income – Hunting legendary animals and selling their pelts can become a lucrative source of income. Players low on cash can target lucrative prey like Legendary Bucks and Bears.

Lower risk – Keeping legendary pelts long term raises the risk of them being lost or damaged. Selling them immediately avoids this.

Cons of Selling Legendary Pelts

There are also a few drawbacks to consider when selling legendary pelts:

Repurchasing costs money – You‘ll have to re-buy the pelt from the trapper to craft with it later. This can add up, especially for rare pelts.

Wasting unique materials – Legendary animals drop unique materials like fangs that are required for crafting special trinkets. Selling the pelt means losing access to these.

Lost immersion – From a roleplaying perspective, hastily selling legendary pelts feels out of character for a veteran hunter like Arthur.

Delayed crafting – You can‘t craft clothing until re-purchasing the pelt, which interrupts crafting plans.

Hard to re-track – Legendary animals don‘t respawn. Once sold, re-acquiring some pelts may prove difficult.

Pros of Keeping Legendary Pelts

Now let‘s examine some benefits of holding onto legendary pelts:

Craft gear immediately – Keeping the pelt allows instant crafting of unique trapper clothing as soon as you visit him. No need to re-buy pelts.

Save money – As mentioned above, keeping pelts avoids having to re-purchase them from the trapper at a markup. This saves dollars long term.

Access unique materials – Special ingredients like legendary tatanka bison horns can only be retrieved from an unskinned carcass. Selling denies you these.

Build collection – Accumulating a stockpile of legendary pelts allows completing your collection faster. Especially useful for 100% completionist players.

Immersive roleplaying – A hunter in tune with nature would use every part of legendary animals rather than selling them off. Keeping pelts fits Arthur‘s character.

Tips for Managing Legendary Pelts

When deciding whether to sell or keep legendary pelts, keep these tips in mind:

• Sell duplicates – You only need one pelt from each legendary animal to craft every item. Sell extras for profit.
• Prioritize rare pelts – Keep hold of rarer pelts like the Tatanka Bison that are needed for special outfits.
• Don‘t hoard – Storing too many pelts will overwhelm your inventory. Sell ones you won‘t use soon.
• Unlock crafting – Ensure you sell the pelt to the trapper at least once to make items craftable.
• Use provisions – Transfer unneeded pelts to your provisions at camp to free up inventory space.

What to Craft with Legendary Pelts

Legendary pelts are required to craft some of the most powerful clothing and trinkets. Here are top items to craft:

• Legend of the East Satchel – Unlocks all satchel capacity upgrades. Needs multiple legendary pelts.
• Legendary Buck & Fox Flop Hat – Perk reduces weapon degradation by 10%.
• Legendary Bison Fringe Jacket – Warm outfit with perfect bison pelt.
• Legendary Buck Antler Trinket – Increases quality of looted animal parts.
• Legendary Panther Eye Trinket – Boosts clear weather encounters.

Legendary Coyote Pelt Crafting

Specifically, the Legendary Coyote Pelt can be used to craft the following unique items:

• Legendary Coyote Flop Hat – Costs $22, protects from sun exposure.
• Legendary Coyote Half Chaps – Costs $18, increases horse bonding XP.
• Trapper Wrangler Jacket – Made from perfect sheep and legendary coyote pelts.

The coyote is one of the most common legendary animals, making its pelt a bit less valuable than rarer prey. I‘d recommend selling the coyote pelt once you‘ve crafted the items above you want, as it‘s easier to re-acquire later.

Valuable Hunting Advice

As an avid Red Dead hunter, here are my top tips for managing pelts:

• Use a bow and improved arrows for clean kills that preserve pelt quality.
• Target predators like cougars, foxes, wolves for valuable furs. Herbivore pelts are generally cheaper.
• Prioritize 3 star animal kills to ensure perfect pelts for crafting.
• Utilize hunter vision to spot distant prey and study their pelt rating.
• Skin carcasses immediately and stow the pelt to prevent decay.

Follow these tips and you‘ll be drowning in top quality pelts in no time!

Final Take – Sell Legendary Pelts

In summary, I typically recommend selling legendary pelts once you have crafted your desired items with them. The immediate cash and convenient access through the trapper outweighs the costs. Players low on funds will benefit greatly from pelt profits.

That said, keeping them does provide immersive roleplaying value and saves you money down the road. Evaluate your crafting needs and financial situation to decide.

I hope this detailed guide gives you all the information needed to manage your legendary pelts effectively. Let me know if you have any other Red Dead hunting questions!